Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello, just saw this and thought it looked interesting, I know you posted it a while ago, but I thought since I read it, I would just put in my two-cents of what I thought.
I liked it, I feel like you have a lot more you can do to develop the characters, which I guess you might have already done in the following chapters that I will read soon. Like the person above me said, I would like to see more of Vern interacting with her people and showing how they are different from the other tribes, and just a plain little more elaboration on the different tribes themselves.
Over all, I liked it and I think you can take it far, I look forward to clicking on chapter two.
Sailor.
Hey Vox,

I'm Tanya and I decided to check out your first chapter. Here are my thoughts:
You have created a very interesting world and although I'm a big fan of events happening quickly, I think this is all too fast. I mean, you have three chapters here on one page. Couldn't you elaborate each chapter a little more? Let us see 'Vern' interact with her people and get a feeling of how they are. Maybe you could watch two of them sparring and include the thought here that they aren't very good fighters and so on, instead of info dumping it all.
Personally, that third chapter makes absolutely no sense to me. Vern attacks Gattlin but leaves him that way? No way in he**. If it happened to me, I'd chop his own wings right off. Finito! You don't show us how she feels, we have no idea what pain she feels, what her thoughts are. Yes, she can pack a mean kick, but so what if she does nothing about it? She has a knife and all she does is carve lines? Again, no way. I'd stab him. Through the heart. Period. So you have to show us why Vern doesn't. Why she hesitates. Why she lets him live when he's taken away what's the most precious to her; her ability to fly...
Hope this helps,
Tanya
thanks, everybody who posted!
I've been working on this one lately (Yeah, it's been a year since I posted it here...) and it's shaping up nicely. The characters have continued to evolve.
Please feel free to check out the second installment--and the third and fourth, which are coming soon.
Thanks!
-Voxina
Good start. Great use of language. But I have a few things to note. You should merge the mini chapters into one single chapter. Alos, you should slow down the pace as things happen very quicly, also suddenly switching the POV from the girls to Gattlin's is pretty confusing. Nonethless and interesting beginning, go Voxina!
Hello vox nihili.
I keep repeating this over and over again in my critiques, please keep your simile in context with what's happening. What do dinos have to do with wind?
How do these two sentences connect? When your writing, ensure that sentences follow through logically.
I don't think there's anything wrong with having such thoughts in her mind. She's trying to be prudent after all.
This is info dumping. Info dumping is when you are telling to us explicitly as to what's happening in your story.
This is info dumping too. Do we need all know all that background information about your race?
Overall impressions:
I noticed that with many authors in the fantasy forum, they tend to focus more on the minute to minute details rather than writing with a particular purpose or theme in mind. Let me ask you this: Why are you writing this fantasy? What message do you want to express to us? What you have here doesn't do that, it's more like a play by play of a rescue attempt.
You should also show more of how their society works to help the audience get a better understanding of your story. We know that they are winged creatures, but that isn't much to work with. And what about your main character? Doesn't she feel anything for what's happened here?
Slow down your story and expand on the details (how, why, what, when and who). Do not tell us what's happening, but give examples where that is the case. Refer to this article, written by another fellow instructor on the site. I assure you, it will get you up and going with creative writing: topic39769.html
Good luck.
Andy.